MERS v. Robinson… Big Win For Robinson in California Quite Title Case
MERS Gets It’s ASS Handed To It!
BIG Win Over MERS Download Court Order Here
On January 11, 2012, Defendants filed a civil action in the
Los Angeles County Superior Court to quiet title to the Property
and expunge the Deed of Trust.
I. Background
On January 11,2012, Defendants filed a civil action in the Los Angeles County Superior Court to quiet title to the Property and expunge the Deed of Trust. See Compl. 130. Defendants named United Pacific Mortgage – the original Lender under the Deed of Trust, as a defendant in the quiet title action; however, Defendants did not name MERS – the nominee of United Pacific Mortgage, as a party or provide any notice of the lawsuit to MERS. Id. ,33. Because United Pacific Mortgage did not appear in the action, Defendants secured a default judgment, thereby expunging the Deed of Trust on the Property. Id. , 35, Ex. 4. On April 25, 2013, Defendants recorded the judgment expunging the Deed of Trust on the Property in the Official Records of the Recorder’s Office of Los Angeles County as instrument number 20130621913. Id.
. . .
A. Plaintiffs Fail to State a Claim under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 762.010
The gravamen of the parties’ dispute raises a single, all-important question: Were Plaintiffs entitled to notice of Defendants , quiet title action before Defendants brought that action in Califomia state court? Defendants unsurprisingly answer this question in the negative, reasoning that Plaintiffs were not entitled to notice of the quiet title action because Plaintiffs are merely the nominee or agent of the Lender under the Deed of Trust and therefore have no
independent interest in the Property. See Mot. 14:19-26; see also Mot. 18:19-12 (“Plaintiffs’ claim of ownership, and of the rights of a beneficiary with status as a party in interest, is strictly a fiction. “). Plaintiffs, on the other hand, answer in the affirmative, declaring that as the identified “beneficiary of record” under the Deed of Trust, they have an interest in the Property sufficient to entitle them to notice of Defendants’ quiet title action. See Opp. 2:14-16 (“As the plainly identified beneficiary of record under a deed of trust, MERS claimed an interest that entitled it to so notice.”). For the reasons explained infra, the Court must side with Defendants. Plaintiffs were not entitled to notice of the quiet title action.
[MERS et al Lost on ALL Counts]
The Court therefore DISMISSES Plaintiffs’ section 762.010 claim to set aside the judgment in the quiet title action WITH LEAVE TO AMEND.
. . .
The Court thus DISMISSES Plaintiffs’ slander of title claim WITH LEAVE TO AMEND.
. . .
Because Plaintiffs here present no other viable state law claims for relief, they necessarily fail to assert a claim for cancellation of instruments as well. See Reade, 2013 U.S.Dist. LEXIS 160681, at *26. Accordingly, the Court DISMISSES the claim WITH LEAVE TO AMEND.
. . .
The Court thus DISMISSES Plaintiffs’ claim for declaratory relief WITH LEAVE TO AMEND.
IV. Conclusion
Thus, for the foregoing reasons, the Court GRANTS Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss. If Plaintiffs wish to file an amended complaint, they must do so by March 3, 2014. Failure to file an amended complaint by this date will result in the dismissal with prejudice of the action.
Download Court Order Here
Download MERS Complaint Here
Financial Halo
ABOUT FINANCIAL HALO
Financial Halo was launched to solve a major concern in the U.S. for 90 million families: debt.
Month after month, year after year, good hard-working people are responsibly paying their bills on time each month but are not getting anywhere financially. Most people would agree, the game of life is all about INCREASING YOUR NET WORTH.
This is the most important formula in your life: Net Worth = Assets minus Liabilities (debts). What most people do is focus on increasing their assets, and that is a good thing. But it is also true that reducing and removing liabilities dramatically and effectively increases net worth. We’re going to show you how to do BOTH.
FIND OUT HOW – PLAY THE VIDEO BELOW
Our Mission Statement is our promise to you:
“To enhance, preserve and protect the financial well-being of those who place their trust in us, helping people to develop financial strategies to overcome stress by providing proven, high-integrity products and services that exceed expectations while removing debt, anxiety and worry from our customers lives. We will heal relationships and save families from the burden of financial uncertainty.”
Over the last decade, watching the debt load of Americans increase year after year and seeing the numbers of people in financial crisis multiply has been a sobering experience.
If families are going to survive and thrive, THIS CANNOT CONTINUE AND MUST STOP.
Click The Button Below For Detailed Information
Click Here